Refer A Friend



We are happy to announce Mark Matthews and Amanda Barnes are the 2016 Winners of the 5 Star Home/Auto Professional  Award! This award is given to the top 7% of agents based on a survey. Congratulations to you both! 



Specialized home, auto, and business insurance in Pickerington and Canal Winchester, OH

We are an independently owned and operated agency that delivers broad and flexible insurance and risk management solutions in Pickerington, Ohio and throughout Central Ohio.  We’ve served individuals, families, and businesses for years and our staff has over 40 years of experience.  We’re two-time 5-Star Award winners and are ranked in the top 1% of all insurance agencies in Central Ohio.  We’re fully committed to giving every client the best insurance experience possible and to ensuring that each client makes the best insurance investments.

Coverages and Policies

We work with a variety of different insurance carriers in order to give our clients the best selections of coverage and policy options.  These options include the many personal and commercial programs we offer; home, auto, and business coverage among them.  We also offer comprehensive programs for specific industries, including contracting and manufacturing.

You can save on your home and auto insurance by combining policies for these two types of insurance.  See our home & auto page and/or ask an agent about this combination to learn more. 

Services and our approach

We know that whether you’re looking for insurance to secure yourself, a business, or your dependents, you want a balanced solution; not a solution based just on price.  That’s why we assess your needs, work closely with you, and support you throughout the life of your policy.  We find solutions that are balanced between full protection and cost and we manage risk and claims.  This means that we help you reduce costs and resolve claims quickly.

We monitor policies regularly and stay in touch with you in order to be aware of any changes in your life that can affect coverages.  This way, your policy is always effective and your rates are always appropriate.

We’re also always available, which means that when it’s during business hours, we answer the phone in three rings or less.  You always talk to a person, and if you need to reach us through other means like text, email, or in person, we’ll be there for you. 

Please contact us or give us a call to learn more.  You can also request a quote if you’re ready to start on a policy.

Related Links:


I am big fan of MMA Insurance Agency since my first experience 5 years ago. My wife and I were purchasing a new home for our family to grow. I had asked Mark for a quote for home owners coverage. I was amazed with the cost considering I was purchasing a bigger home, more coverage and received a lower annual premium. I then decided to have him quote our auto coverage as well. I figured he wouldn’t be able to go much lower since we were preferred clients of a very well know insurance company. Not only was MMA Insurance Agency able to beat the competition, we were getting coverage for both auto and home policies for the same price that we were getting just for our auto insurance with the other company. It’s as if we were getting our home owners coverage for free. I have since recommended my friends, family and clients to MMA Insurance Agency for insurance needs, as they have been able to save each and everyone of them.
Bill Holliday
I just wanted to take a moment and thank you again for everything that you do for us. My wife and I are very happy that we made the switch to MMA Insurance. We were with Nationwide Insurance for over 7 years together and 8 years on my own. After the initial consultation I never heard from my agent, unless he wanted to “up sell” me something. As you know a lot changed in our lifestyles in that time period; Marriage, Kids, Cars and Home Ownership. We originally switched because you were able to get us 2 times the coverage and a large Umbrella Policy for the same rates. We have now been insured with you for almost 2 years and you have already recommended we switch our Insurance carrier to save us money at no cost or reduction of coverage. Thanks again for giving us Peace-of-Mind!
Chris and Janee Bryant
I wanted to send a message to you and let you know what a privilege it has been to work with you entire team to secure my home, auto, umbrella and soon to be health insurance through your company and team. Everyone I have spoken with (Donna, Amanda, Ina) has been amazingly helpful, well informed and highly professional. I am very happy to be one of your new clients and know that I will happily refer you and your team to anyone. Thank you again. Having lived out of the country for five years, now buying a home and setting life up again in the U.S. is kind of an intimidating process, but thanks to you and your team, you have all taken a lot of that fear and stress (of making bad decisions) out of that process for me. Respectfully, Andy M
Andy M