CALL US:
614.454.3869

Refer A Friend

Meet Our Team

  • Mark Matthews

    Agency Principal
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Mark is the founder and Agency Principal of MMA Insurance and has a degree in Business Management. He also holds the Certified Insurance Counselors (CIC) designation. He has grown MMA Insurance into one of the area’s largest independent Insurance Agencies in Central Ohio. Additionally, he has served on the Boards of the Diley Ridge Medical Center, Pickerington Area Chamber of Commerce, Violet Festival, and Liberty Union Athletic Boosters. Mark’s goal is to give you the coverage you need at the lowest cost.

  • Amanda Barnes

    Client Service Manager
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Born and raised in Circleville, Ohio, She married her wonderful husband in 2003 and moved to Pickerington in 2004. Amanda is a proud mother to three beautiful girls, ages 22 and 6 year old twins. She worked with the electric company for the state of Maine for several years and then became a stay at home mother until her twins were 1. She starting with MMA Insurance in March 2010. She has since became the client service manager, claims specialist, a licensed insurance agent and a Notary Public. Additionally, Amanda is licensed in Property and Casualty Insurance. 

  • Rick LaVeer

    Agent
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Rick has been a leader in the insurance industry for over 21 years. He has held positions as an agent, trainer, sales manager, sales director, sales vice president, sales consultant , coach and mentor. He has managed over a 1000 agents throughout his career. One thing he learned along the way, is that while training others, there is always an opportunity for the coach to learn from the player.

  • Jennifer Stadler

    Licensed Client Service Agent
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Jennifer is originally from Celina, Ohio, but moved to the Columbus area in June of 1997 and is the mother of 3 boys. She previously worked for a small glass company as the office manager for over 3 years and has been with MMA Insurance since January of 2012. Since then, she became licensed in Property and Casualty Insurance as of July 2014 and enjoys working with and helping our clients. 

  • Christy Senalik

    Licensed Client Service Agent
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Christy is goal oriented and takes pride in her work. Christy graduated with a Bachelor’s degree from Ohio Dominican University in 2003. She has been with MMA Insurance since October 2014. As a Client Service Representative, Christy is focused on communication and enjoys building a rapport with her clients. Christy is licensed in Property & Casualty Insurance. 

     

  • Crystal Cusick

    Licensed Agent
    Office: 614-454-4631
    Fax: 614-833-3223
    670 Windmiller Drive STE B
    Pickerington OH 43147
    Get Directions >>

    Crystal Cusick is a licensed agent and Notary Public with nearly 15 years of insurance industry background. 

     

    Having a passion for home and community, Crystal was raised in the Reynoldsburg/Pickerington area, where she currently resides with her husband, Aaron, and her two sons, Adrian and Chase.

     

    Utilizing extensive experience and knowledge of the insurance industry, Crystal’s primary focus is in addressing overall client needs.