A Client-First Approach to Insurance

At MMA Insurance Agency, we’re committed
to working for you.





Insurance in Pickerington, New Albany
and Surrounding Areas of Ohio

Also serving the insurance needs of Columbus, OH, Canal Winchester, OH and Reynoldsburg, OH

Smarter insurance starts with experts who think a little differently — a company which understands your industry and what’s on the line for you. As an independently owned and operated agency in the Greater Columbus, OH area, we’ve built our business on creating innovative solutions to even the toughest risk management challenges.

Our staff has over 40 years of experience serving individuals, families, and businesses. We’re a two-time 5-Star Award winner and are ranked in the top 1% of all insurance agencies in Central Ohio. We’re fully committed to giving every client the best insurance experience possible and ensuring that each client makes the best insurance investments. As your insurance advisor, we help you make smart decisions – protecting you from the unexpected and planning for the predictable.

Whether your obtaining personal car insurance in the Pickerington or New Albany Ohio areas, or commercial insurance for your small business—that commitment doesn’t change.

Our Partners

Forging solid relationships among clients, community, and industry affiliates is at the core of MMA Insurance Agency’s philosophy. We take pride in the great working relationships we developed through our participation in key organizations.

Partner National Alliance

Partner Ohio Insurance Agents

Partner Pickerington Chamber

New Albany Chamber

There’s more to insurance than
the price of the policy

Explore our interactive graphics and learn about your unique risks
and the related insurance solutions.

Recent Posts

Valentine’s Day & Chocolate: The Dangers of Chocolate for Dogs

| Family, Home Insurance, Insurance, Personal Insurance, Renters insurance, Thankful | No Comments
Valentine’s Day is a great time to show the ones you love just how much they mean . While we spoil our loved ones with flowers, balloons, conversation hearts & of course, chocolate, our…

Roost Smart Leak and Freeze Detector Pilot.

| Family, Home Insurance, Insurance, Personal Insurance, Renters insurance | No Comments
We’re currently offering our clients an opportunity to take part in a Roost smart leak and freeze detector pilot. It requires you to have a smartphone & wi-fi in your…

Medicare Advantage vs Medicare Supplement Plans

| Employee Benefits, Health Insurance, Insurance, Medicare | No Comments
Medicare Advantage vs Medicare Supplement Plans. Jeff Metzger has the inside scoop. He can be reached at our office 614.834.6624, his direct email is jeffm@mmains.net #MMAInsurance #Pickerington #NewAlbany #IndependentAgent #ChoiceMatters…

Medicare Supplement Insurance Coverage without the Confusion

| Employee Benefits, Health Insurance, Insurance, Medicare, Specialty Insurance | No Comments
Medicare Supplement Insurance coverage without the confusion Choosing a Medicare Supplement insurance plan can be overwhelming. But you don’t have to go it alone—I’m here to help. Erie Family Life…